Monday's shake-up in the C-Suite at SAP may come as a surprise to some, but not to UberCEO. Many media outlets have commented on SAP's weak financial performance and unhappy customers and employees which led to Leo Apotheker's sudden departure. But there are deeper questions facing SAP regarding the company's business strategy and direction. 
For years, SAP represented multi-million dollar software promises to its customers. They often delivered on those promises by creating operational efficiencies at tremendous expense in time and dollars to their customers. However, there were times SAP failed to deliver on its promises. As Oracle expanded and deepened its expertise through its acquisitions (not without its own missteps), SAP always seemed the follower and today is the bride left at the altar. Innovation is dead at SAP as its new co-chief executives Bill McDermott and Jim Hagenmann Snabe already recognize. Or is it?
Over the past couple of years, SAP spent millions (actually billions according to inside sources) on the future of enterprise software - Business byDesign which will be officially launched in the middle of 2010. UberCEO has seen SAP's future and we like what we've seen. The solution is rock-solid and flexible...just what SAP enterprise customers demand. And therein lies SAP's dilemma.
Business byDesign doesn't fit the SAP business model. Like most cloud-computing solutions, the sales and deployment models are different from enterprise software and so is the pricing. While Business byDesign is targeted at the ever-promising SMB (Small and Medium Sized Business), the solution which was designed and engineered to be scaled to grow with your business may also suit the needs of SAP's larger, existing enterprise customers and leave them scratching their heads asking themselves why they spent millions on SAP over the last decade.
Say what you want about Larry Ellison and Oracle, but Larry actually understood the difference between what the Oracle brand means to its enterprise customers and wisely launched a cloud-computing, enterprise solution for SMBs under separate brand NetSuite. This is where SAP's strategy needs altering.
SAPs current enterprise business model is about a large sales force, booking millions in software licenses and maintenance and increasing both to stay ahead of inflation while expanding the new customer base which is continuously more difficult to secure. SAP's brand is identified by the large enterprise sale. Business byDesign, on the other hand, is a low-cost-of-sales and deployment model. The pricing model actually works...the more you eat, the more you pay but it conflicts entirely with SAP's brand perception by its customers.
What SAP needs to do now, is extract the Business byDesign brand from the mothership to get what should be a rapidly growing business out of the jaws of a declining behemoth. If the new leadership at SAP can execute this critical surgery on the struggling patients, both businesses have a strong chance of developing successful strategies for the future.
Let us know what you think of SAP and it's challenge evolving to a cloud computing company with Business byDesign.